ID |
FCQ |
FO |
Entity/ies
described |
Template (Y/N) |
Instantiates
Template |
Source |
Link |
bfo_dd_1 |
Can
[] exist on its own or is this entity a property of another entity or depends
on at least 1 other entity (a bearer)? |
BFO |
own:
Independent Continuant |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_2 |
Does
[] always have some matter (space and mass) as a part that persists in time? |
BFO |
Material
Entity |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_3 |
Does
[] exist (by evolution or design) to realise specific processes? |
BFO |
Function |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_4 |
Does
[] exist because the bearer is in a specific situation? |
BFO |
Role |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_5 |
Does
[] require at least 2 bearers to exist? |
BFO |
Relational
quality |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_6 |
Does
[] require some further process to be realised? |
BFO |
Realizable
entity |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_7 |
Does
this describe a process whereby there has been a substantial change? |
BFO |
History
or process profile |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_8 |
Does
this describe the rate of change or the actual changes that are occurring? |
BFO |
rate:
History; actual: process profile |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_9 |
How
many dimensions does [] have? |
BFO |
Region |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_10 |
Is
[] a collection of disjoint self-standing single objects? |
BFO |
Object
aggregate |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_11 |
Is
[] a moment or does it take longer? |
BFO |
moment:
0D temp region; longer: 1D temp region |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_12 |
Is
[] a proper part of an object, rather than a member of? |
BFO |
object) |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_13 |
Is
[] bounded, partially or wholly, by a material entity or is it a portion in
space? |
BFO |
Immaterial
Entity |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_14 |
Is
[] present at different times (the whole object (not only some of its parts),
or is it occurring in time? |
BFO |
Continuant |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_15 |
Is
the [] a spatial projection of a portion of space-time? |
BFO |
Spatial
region |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_16 |
Is
this [] the boundary of what is occurring? |
BFO |
Process
boundary |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_17 |
May
[] be shared/ copied between a number of bearers? |
BFO |
Yes:
Generically dependent continuant; No: Specifically dependent continuant |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
bfo_dd_18 |
What
is []'s relation to the universal spatiotemporal region? |
BFO |
portion
of: Spatiotemporal region; projection of: Temporal region |
Y |
|
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
dolce_dd_1 |
Is
[] something that is happening or occurring? |
DOLCE |
Perdurant |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_2 |
Is
[] wholly present at any time of its existence? |
DOLCE |
Endurant |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_3 |
Does
[] exist neither in space nor in time or does so because some other items
that are not among its parts occupy that region? |
DOLCE |
Abstract |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_4 |
Is
[] something that can be preceived or measured (like color, size, smell,
etc.,)? |
DOLCE |
Quality |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_5 |
Is
[] an attribute of a (physical) object? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Physical Quality No:Temp Entity |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_6 |
Is
[] an attribute of something that is happening or occurring? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Temporal Quality No: Abstract Quality |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_7 |
Are
you able to be present, participate in []? |
DOLCE |
Yes:Event
No:Stative |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_8 |
Are
you able to undergo, experience, or be subjected to []? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
State No: Process |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_9 |
Is
[] Atomic, i.e., has no subdivisions of it and has a definite end point? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Achievement No: Accomplishment |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_10 |
Is
[] a collection of well defined objects? |
DOLCE |
Set |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_11 |
Is
[] a piece of information about something that exists or has happened? |
DOLCE |
Fact |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_12 |
Is
[] a location of or occupied by some object? |
DOLCE |
Region |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_13 |
Is
[] a collection of things, regardless of their spatial or other differences? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Arbitrary Sum No: Temp Entity |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_14 |
Does
[] not take up space or does [] need some other object to exist in, or is []
a role played by some object? (e.g., a student) |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Non Physical Endurant No: Physical Endurant |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_15 |
Does
[] exist insofar its host exist (like holes, bumps, boundaries, or spots of
color)? |
DOLCE |
Yes;
Feature No: Temp entity |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_16 |
Is
[] something that cannot be counted, or only in specific quantities? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Amount of Matter No: Physical Object |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
dolce_dd_17 |
Is
[] dependent on a community of (>1) agents or embedded in some social
setting? |
DOLCE |
Yes:
Social Object No: Mental Object |
Y |
|
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
coffee_fcq1 |
Can
the `brewing method' entity be mapped to any perdurant branch entities in the
DOLCE foundational ontology? |
DOLCE |
Perdurant |
N |
|
this
library |
|
coffee_fcq2 |
Does
`pouring (a drink)' require some further process to be realised? |
BFO |
Realizable
entity |
N |
bfo_dd_6 |
Bernabé,
C.H., Keet, C.M., Khan, Z.C., Mahlaza, Z. A method to improve alignments
between domain and foundational ontologies. 13th International Conference on
Formal Ontology in Information Systems 2023 (FOIS'23). IOS Press, FAIA vol.
377, 125-139. 18-20 July Sherbrooke, Canada. |
|
coffee_fcq3 |
Are
you able to be present, participate in `pouring (a drink)'? |
DOLCE |
Yes:Event
No:Stative |
N |
dolce_dd_7 |
Keet,
C.M., Khan, M.T., Ghidini, C. Ontology Authoring with FORZA. 22nd ACM
International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CIKM'13).
ACM proceedings, pp569-578. Oct. 27 - Nov. 1, 2013, San Francisco, USA. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|